What Milburn's masterclass can teach us about comms
How Alan Milburn used human, authentic communications and a carefully planned media strategy to make his review of young people and work dominate the news agenda.
Alan Milburn's long-awaited review of Britain's million young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) is as impressive for its communications as for its ambition.
Behind the report's playful "NEET Zero" headline were calls to cut the NEET rate from 13% to around 5% by 2036, with under-25s moving from sickness and disability benefits to a new youth allowance, backed by a guaranteed route into work or training.
For anyone in communications, the real lesson is in how Milburn sold it to the country. For more than a week, anticipation and the report's publication dominated the news agenda. Even his most ardent critics would have to accept how well he handled the PR.
What set that approach apart was how 'human' it felt. That happens to be Cambridge Dictionary's Word of the Year, announced this week and chosen to reflect a renewed value placed on connection and authenticity.
That's a decent brief for those of us in comms, and it's something Milburn's launch embodied. He was candid about the downsides and the costs, framing the crisis as a moral imperative about real young people.
Compare that with AI slop and over-rehearsed government-speak that dominate so much of what we read.
The way the report was delivered reminds us that people still respond to people. Let's take a closer look at the comms tactics behind his approach.
Rolling the pitch
Milburn's team spent the week ahead of publication rolling the pitch and teasing announcements.
- Thursday 12 November. Channel 4 News and ITV's Robert Peston were already previewing the report and exploring its likely clash with backbenchers over sickness benefits.
- Friday 13 November. Milburn told The Times that the plan would need significant upfront investment and take a decade to pay back. He also admitted that some claimants would initially receive less support. Burnham called it a "watershed moment" but declined to give a "blanket assurance" that he would accept it all the recommendations.
- Weekend 14-15 November. Milburn made the case for a legal opportunity guarantee on LBC, then appeared on Sunday with Laura Kuenssberg to warn that there was "no such thing as a free lunch".
- Monday 16 November. By now, the employer story was out: a phased National Insurance cut, starting in retail and hospitality.
By Tuesday, the most contentious elements were already out. Crucially, they had come from Milburn himself, in his own words. Because each day brought a fresh angle, the story built over time, and the team kept a handle on the messaging.
Pre-briefings can come at a cost. Rolling the pitch works best when the people who have to deliver or buy into something don't feel they've read about it in the papers first. That is where internal comms come in.
Internal comms: bringing everyone with him
By the time the report reached newsrooms, the people who needed to deliver on its recommendations were already well briefed.
That work started months earlier. Milburn engaged with an expert panel that included people with lived experience. Through close consultation, he also heard directly from young people themselves and from a wide range of employers.
He also secured political buy-in early. Before Burnham had even moved into No 10, Milburn was holding private talks with him.
That groundwork put him in good stead on launch day, when the political sequence was just as carefully rehearsed as the media rollout:
- Cabinet first. Milburn presented his recommendations to Burnham's Cabinet on Tuesday morning, and ministers endorsed the approach.
- Then the parliamentary party. Burnham met Labour MPs before the press conference. These are the same backbenchers who forced the last government to water down its welfare reforms.
- Then parliament. McFadden made a statement to the Commons the same day. He accepted Milburn's first two recommendations and echoed his messaging: "we value you, we believe in you".
- Then the prime minister, again. On BBC Breakfast, Burnham promised to "move quickly" on the recommendations, saying he wanted to get stuck in.
Packing the news agenda
Once he secured the political buy-in, the message was cascaded through the media. Milburn's diary was jam-packed:
- 07:40, Sky News. An upfront admission that some young people would be worse off at first.
- 08:05, BBC Breakfast. Get on with it, but it will take time.
- 08:20, Radio 4 Today. A moment of choice, where half measures would not do.
- 09:25, LBC. Candid on employer National Insurance: he understood the government's reasons, but employers said it made hiring young people harder.
- By 10:00. "For the vast majority of young people, work beats welfare every single time." Then came a press conference at Google's London offices.
- Evening. Channel 4 News led on "work, not welfare".
By half past nine, he had appeared on nearly half a dozen national programmes and not once sounded like he was reading from a script. His argument stayed the same throughout, but he found fresh messaging for each interview.
Knowing your audience
Broadcast only reaches so far. At 278 pages, the full report is written with policy wonks in mind, complete with annexes and data tables. It also came with a 36-page executive summary for readers who need to understand the changes but don't have a spare afternoon.
Most people will only ever read the summary, if that, so it has to be easy to understand and stand on its own. The same goes for the headline. "NEET Zero" gives people who will never open the report a memorable phrase.
It's clever wordsmithing, but it does risk the same fate as "Net Zero" itself. Once a slogan becomes a target, opponents can turn it into a stick to beat you with.
Each audience could hear its own reassurances and feel ownership of part of the story. Employers got hiring payments and a National Insurance change; backbenchers were assured that this was about improving lives rather than saving cash; and young people were told they were not the problem.
The messenger's tone: authentic northern sensibilities
None of this would have worked without the right spokesperson. As a fellow northerner, I loved hearing a North East accent carry wall-to-wall coverage.
His region has Britain's highest NEET rate, at almost one in five, according to the Centre for Social Justice.
Milburn has seen the issue first-hand, which gives him lived authenticity. He is direct, too. Asked whether young people could sue over a legal guarantee, he said: "We're going to avoid that elephant trap, believe me." He admitted some would be worse off at first.
Journalists love this stuff. The alternative is the well-worn, dreary "we are carefully considering the recommendations" safety net we've grown accustomed to in political comms.
The bigger picture: what government comms can learn
Milburn's approach raises broader questions about the quality of government comms. Boris Johnson's former communications director called for an overhaul in 2021, with tighter control from the centre. The Institute for Government's response warned that official comms "should not be about spinning headlines or shaping the political narrative".
Keir Starmer's former No.10 communications director Steph Driver also revisited the question, arguing that government should move from "announce and defend" to "discuss and decide".
Milburn's review felt very "discuss and decide" in its approach.
Beveridge, Leveson, Chilcot… Milburn?
One more test of a report's comms is whether people are still talking about it years later. Like Beveridge, Leveson and Chilcot, some reports outlive their recommendations and become seared into the public consciousness.
Should we add Milburn to the list?
Whether its policies are taken on board is for Parliament to decide, but as a lesson in comms best practice, it has certainly earned its place.

Jake Setterfield is a director of Fieldcraft Communications, which brings clarity to communications for organisations advancing science, building infrastructure and shaping policy.
Further reading
Keeping a finger on the pulse of the NHS as communicators
Group chat think: A warning for communicators from the US midterm elections
England’s new regionalism: why politics, place and PR need to reconnect

